Shopify and BigCommerce are the two names that dominate ecommerce platform comparisons, yet they take opposite approaches to the same job. Shopify keeps the core product stripped down and clean, then lets you add what you need through its enormous app store. BigCommerce ships more features out of the box and charges no transaction fees, but its interface takes longer to learn. I built test stores on both, pushed their checkout flows, and compared real monthly costs at a few different order volumes. Here is what I found.
Disclosure: This page has affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Quick verdict
Pick Shopify if getting a store live fast matters to you, you sell across social and want the widest app selection, and you are comfortable using Shopify Payments to avoid transaction fees. Pick BigCommerce if your catalog is large or complex, you want native features that Shopify charges app fees for, and transaction fees are a sticking point. Shopify wins for most new and mid-sized sellers; BigCommerce earns its place once your catalog and requirements grow past what the simpler platforms handle well.
Shopify vs BigCommerce at a glance
Here is the side-by-side before the detail.
| Feature | Shopify | BigCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $39/mo | $39/mo |
| Transaction fees | Up to 2% (waived with Shopify Payments) | None |
| App store | 8,000+ apps | Smaller marketplace |
| Built-in features | Moderate, app-extended | More native features |
| Large catalog support | Good up to mid-size | Strong, built for complex catalogs |
| Ease of setup | Very easy | Moderate learning curve |
| Multichannel selling | Excellent | Good |
| Best for | New stores, social sellers, fast launch | Complex catalogs, B2B, growing merchants |
Shopify wins on ease and ecosystem; BigCommerce wins on native features and zero transaction fees.
Pricing and transaction fees
Both platforms start at the same monthly rate, so at first glance neither looks cheaper. The gap opens when you count transaction fees. Shopify charges up to 2% per transaction when you process payments through a third-party gateway. On a $50,000 monthly revenue store, that is $1,000 per month in fees before you have paid for a single app.
BigCommerce charges no transaction fees on any plan, regardless of which payment processor you use. That is a material cost advantage for stores with volume or stores that cannot or will not use Shopify Payments.
- Using Shopify Payments: Shopify eliminates the fee entirely, and the gap shrinks.
- Using a preferred gateway: BigCommerce is the cheaper platform at almost every revenue level.
- App costs: Shopify stores often need paid apps for features BigCommerce includes, which closes some of the difference the other way.
Neither platform is clearly cheaper in all cases. Run the math on your actual gateway and app needs before committing.
Built-in features vs the app store approach
This is the core philosophical difference between the two platforms. Shopify ships a clean, focused core product and assumes you will pull in apps for everything else. BigCommerce ships with more capabilities already installed: native faceted search, more product variant options, B2B tools on some plans, and promotions that Shopify handles through apps.
The Shopify App Store is enormous. With over 8,000 apps, nearly any integration you can think of exists and is usually well-supported. That is genuinely useful. But popular apps like subscriptions, advanced loyalty programs, or deeper wholesale pricing add $20-$100 per month each, and those costs accumulate.
BigCommerce’s marketplace is smaller, which can be a problem for niche requirements. For mainstream needs, though, you will likely find what you need without layering on monthly fees for things that ship as standard features.
Ease of use
Shopify sets the bar for ecommerce onboarding. Product creation, checkout setup, and theme editing are all straightforward. A non-technical seller can have products live and a domain connected in an afternoon without reading documentation.
BigCommerce takes more work. The admin is more detailed, which also means there are more options to configure before your store looks and behaves the way you want. Power users appreciate that extra control; first-time merchants sometimes get stuck on decisions that Shopify would have handled automatically.
Both platforms have 24/7 support and a deep library of help documentation. Neither leaves you without options if something goes wrong.
Catalog depth and B2B
For standard consumer catalogs under a few hundred products, both platforms perform well. The gap becomes obvious at scale.
BigCommerce handles large inventories and complex variant matrices more cleanly. Its faceted filtering works out of the box, and its B2B features on the Enterprise tier are a genuine fit for wholesale and complex pricing rules. Shopify can do this too, but you are adding third-party apps or moving to the expensive Shopify Plus tier to get there.
If your store stocks thousands of SKUs, sells to other businesses with tiered pricing, or needs detailed attribute filtering for buyers, BigCommerce is the platform that was designed for that scenario.
Who should pick which
Choose Shopify if:
- You want the fastest possible path from sign-up to first sale.
- You plan to sell on TikTok, Instagram, or multiple marketplaces and want those integrations to just work.
- You will use Shopify Payments and can avoid the transaction fee entirely.
- Your catalog is straightforward and you expect to find any missing feature in the app store.
Choose BigCommerce if:
- Transaction fees are a cost concern and you need flexibility on payment processors.
- Your catalog is large, complex, or needs strong faceted search without paying for apps.
- You want B2B or wholesale pricing features without upgrading to an enterprise tier.
- You are comfortable spending time on setup in exchange for more built-in capability.
The verdict
For most new stores and sellers who want a quick, polished launch, Shopify wins. Its ecosystem, ease of use, and multichannel tools are the best in the category. BigCommerce earns its place for merchants with complex catalogs, volume that makes transaction fees matter, or requirements that Shopify handles only through expensive apps. Start on Shopify if you are unsure; consider BigCommerce seriously once your catalog and feature list outgrow the simpler path.